FOR DEKALB COUNTY LANDLORDS
Keep It, Fix It, or Exit It
How to decide what to do with a rental property
A tired landlord, a bad tenant, and a bad property are three different problems. Let's figure out which one you have before anyone says "sell."
THE QUESTION THAT STARTS EVERY CONVERSATION
If you didn't already own this property today, knowing everything you know now, would you buy it again?”— M. Emanuel Grubbs
Yes? Keeping it may make sense. No? That doesn't mean sell tomorrow. It means we find out why the answer changed.
GO DEEPER
Click any topic to read more
Keep It: when the property still fits
The property may still be a good asset. Sometimes frustration is temporary, and selling a good property because of a bad six months solves the wrong problem.
Signs keeping it may fit:
- The numbers still work.
- The frustration is recent, not years long.
- You'd buy it again today.
What I do: tell you plainly when you don't have a property problem.
Fix It: when the problem is how the property is run
Sometimes the house isn't the problem. The real problem might be:
- A tenant.
- Repairs that keep piling up.
- Contractors you can't count on.
- A property manager who isn't doing the job.
- Doing too much of the work yourself.
Signs fixing it may fit:
- You like the property but hate managing it.
- One tenant or one repair is causing most of the stress.
- You haven't checked on the property in a long time.
What I do: we look at what's actually wearing you down, and I give you clear recommendations on what to change. I don't manage properties, so putting those changes in place is up to you or a manager you choose. If running it a different way lets you enjoy owning it again, I'll tell you: "I don't think you should sell this property right now."
Exit It: when you're done
Some landlords take an honest look and see it clearly. Even if the tenant, the repairs, and every headache were fixed, they'd still be done. That's not a property problem. That's a decision.
Signs exiting may fit:
- You dread every call about the house.
- It's taking a toll on your family or your health.
- Your plans for the next few years don't include being a landlord.
What I do: list your property in the condition it's in, on the open market, so buyers can compete for it. I'm not the buyer, and I can't promise a price. Nobody honestly can. The market sets it.
Who this is for
Keep It, Fix It, Exit It is the decision framework behind Landlord Exit Representation. It's for rental-property owners who aren't sure they still want to be landlords. It separates the ownership decision from the sales decision.
Who it helps:
- Burned-out landlords.
- Accidental landlords who never planned on owning a rental.
- Investors ready to exit a property.
- Families handling an inherited home or a parent's move.
I serve rental owners across DeKalb County, Georgia, including Decatur, Stone Mountain, Tucker, Lithonia, Clarkston, Chamblee, Doraville, and Brookhaven.
The question "Would you buy it again?" takes history out of the decision. Not "I've owned it forever." Not "My parents owned it." Not "I've already put so much money into it." Just this: does the property still deserve a place in your future?
Some situations are more complex: partners who disagree, several properties, a refinance, or tax questions. Those take more than three choices on a page. We take them one piece at a time and bring in your CPA or attorney when needed.
Example: one owner's keep-or-sell numbers (made up)
This is a made-up example with round numbers. It is not advice or a prediction for your property.
Meet “Pat.” Pat owns a paid-off rental in DeKalb County and is tired of running it.
If Pat keeps it, each year:
- Rent coming in: $18,000
- Taxes, insurance, and repairs: about $6,000
- Saving for big repairs like a roof or HVAC: about $2,000
- Left over: about $10,000 a year, plus Pat’s time and stress
If Pat sells it:
- Estimated sale price: $250,000
- Minus selling costs (broker fee, closing costs, a few repairs): about $25,000
- Estimated walk-away before taxes: about $225,000
The questions Pat has to answer:
- Is about $10,000 a year worth the calls, repairs, and worry?
- What else could $225,000 do for Pat’s goals?
- What would taxes take? (Pat’s CPA answers that one.)
There’s no right answer for everyone. The point is to see the numbers side by side before you decide. In a Property Strategy Session, we do this with your real numbers.
Have questions about tenants, repairs, fees or selling as-is? Visit the landlord FAQ.
You're not behind. You're right on time.
NOT SURE WHICH ONE FITS?
Take the 3-minute Landlord Exit Diagnostic. It shows whether you're leaning toward keep, fix, or exit. Or talk through your property with me. No pressure, and no answer picked ahead of time.